We caught up with Allan Tinkler, commercial director at Anonymised who told us why the resource drought is the one thing he would change this year. It’s a theme that runs throughout our conversation. Having been in the industry for almost 30 years, Allan has seen numbers dwindle. We discuss the challenges that come from approaching AI and Agentic AI as a replacement for humans, rather than a way to free up people’s time to be strategic.

 

What is the one thing you wish everyone knew about AdTech?

AdTech is complex. It’s made more so by companies that don’t add value. Instead, they capture budgets with a black box solution whose promises are too good to be trusted.

Advertising is an experimental exercise that must be constantly optimised by humans, aided by technology. It’s an industry that needs real experts whose role it is to understand what’s behind the curtain and where the real innovations & opportunities lie. Everyone knows that there are bad players out there, but there are plenty more good players. Every agency needs someone to identify them

 

What’s the biggest misconception advertisers have about AdTech?

Advertisers often think that AdTech is more accurate than it is. Marketing isn’t maths. It isn’t science. It’s human.

Technology does not make marketing into science. The misconception that AdTech is going to make marketing an automated science is a real problem in this industry. Too many people, unfortunately including those in leadership roles, believe the machines can do it all for them. But to get anywhere with AdTech, you need the skills and strategy that only a human can provide.

If you could change one thing in the industry, what would it be?

There’s a resource drought happening in the industry today. Technology has been treated as a solve-all and we’ve lost a lot of highly talented people.

I’ve always known that AI would take jobs. But I’d hoped that AI and agentic AI buying would be targeted at aspects of people’s roles that are repeatable and can be turned into automated tasks. Strategic human thinking cannot be done by AI and agents. Instead, they should provide people with the tools to free up their time to dedicate to the parts of their roles that are about developing strategies, creative concepts and meeting people.  What appears to be happening is that businesses believe AI can allow them to reduce their workforce. It’s creating a talent squeeze where fewer people are expected to manage increasingly complex roles. This impacts everything in our industry. Publishers struggle to deliver high quality journalism as they reduce their staff and rely on AI content. Agencies can’t make the most out of their strategic talent because they’re too bogged down in trying to run campaigns. And agency buyers lack the headspace to truly interrogate the ecosystem.

Yes, society needs to move on and embrace the new technology, but it can’t be to the detriment of the human touch.

If I could change one thing in this industry it would be steering companies away from getting rid of talented people, in the mistaken belief that machines will do it for them. We need to move away from ‘shoestring’ operations and give people the time to focus on the strategic work that moves the needle. We need to invest in people. I hope that as we lean more into AI and agentic buying, we use those efficiencies to reinvest in human brilliance.

How can media agencies get the most out of AdTech for their clients?

Agencies get the most out of AdTech when they prioritise agility over the status quo. Too often bigger agencies are stifled by legacy deals and global agreements that prevent media buyers testing new high-performing tools.

This can happen in indies too, not just the networks. However, indies are in a unique position to bypass these challenges and act as nimble advisors. In my experience people across every level at indie agencies are more likely to care about the outcomes for their clients. They speak to their clients every week. They know who they are. Because of that, they care about the results.

To get those results isn’t easy. To succeed, agencies should carve out the space for experts to focus specifically on the emerging tech landscape. People need the space to be out in the industry; to look beyond the smoke and mirrors, see if there is something in the latest AdTech solution and identify the opportunities to investigate. It could be defining one or two people in an agency to own this. Or, it could be giving everyone the time and space to investigate this stuff themselves.

When you consistently present your clients with smart, vetted solutions that they won’t find elsewhere, you move the relationship from a transactional one to a vital strategic partnership.

How do you think advertising will change over the next three years?

Advertising workflows will be simplified and integrated, with humans in the loop supervising AI-driven processes. The hype around AI replacing humans will die out, creating a two-tier system: AI-managed, single-channel campaigns for small businesses and AI-aided, cross-channel campaigns managed by human experts for more professional advertisers.

 

What are you most passionate about achieving this year in media?

We have spent years perfecting the underlying technology required to operate in a restricted ecosystem controlled by privacy and the reduction of traditional signals. That work is now our baseline. Anonymised supports user privacy, reduces leakage and keeps data safe. The way that data and privacy should work.

I’m genuinely excited about being able to take our technology and give agencies and advertisers a competitive advantage. It’s something we’ve done recently with MI Media’s own client, Prostate Cancer UK. The charity faced the challenge of Meta’s healthcare category restrictions, which prevented conversion optimisation. By deploying Anonymised’s Audience Lift to create enriched lookalike audiences, MI Media’s campaign achieved a 35% reduction in cost per acquisition in just two weeks.

What I am most passionate about achieving this year is the rollout of our unique omnichannel solutions. Because our foundations are so robust, we can offer advertisers a level of audience intelligence and cross channel reach that is difficult to find elsewhere. I want to spend this year demonstrating how our bespoke approach to first party data activation provides a genuine competitive advantage. We enable our clients to achieve results that simply weren’t possible under the old models.

Click here to sign up to be alerted when the next in our Media Innovation series is published. Head to our news page to read previous posts in this series about Retail Media.

Anonymised is an AI data platform for incremental audience targeting and campaign measurement – helping advertisers target and measure relevant audiences for increased reach and performance – without using or exposing personal data. Its privacy-enhancing technology couples cross-site data with on-device machine learning to allow accurate targeting and measurement of 100% consented audiences, across all browsers and devices. Its AI technology is crucial for the future of digital advertising since 60% of the web is effectively anonymous, and therefore addressable.

Talk To Us

Want to find out how you can accelerate growth? Drop us a line and our team will be in touch.

triangle
triangle