​​​​​​     ​ 

Marketing Insight: Snickers position as the world’s best selling chocolate bar was under threat

From 2007 to 2009, Snickers was experiencing a sales growth decline and losing market share. It was lagging behind its competitors, threatening its position as the world’s best-selling chocolate bar.

The brand identified that the chocolate bar market was incredibly saturated and that the product was generally a snack purchased on impulse. Snickers’ brand awareness was high but, to stand out in a cluttered market, it needed to create brand fame to stay front of mind when people were reaching for a snack.

Mindful of this task, Snickers’ brand strategy centred around a new creative that would intrinsically link the chocolate bar with the moment that people hungrily seek out a snack. This was the birth of the now famous ‘You’re not you when you’re hungry’ tagline.

Media Innovation: standing out in a saturated market

There were four key actions within a new brand strategy that contributed to the overall success of Snickers’ ‘You’re not you when you’re hungry’ campaign.

  1. The campaign launched with a memorable creative, using a combination of humour and celebrities to convey the core message that people aren’t themselves when they’re hungry and a Snickers bar is the solution to get people back to their usual selves.
  2. The appearance of well-known faces within the creative, as well as endorsements via innovative social media posts, was tailored to the brand’s global audience. Snickers used local celebrities in each market to illustrate the ‘You’re not you when you’re hungry’ messaging.
  3. Snickers expanded from its traditionally young and male target audience to a larger, more diverse audience, with the intention of making the brand relatable to everyone that likes chocolate.
  4. To reach this new broader audience, the brand also updated its marketing mix to include TV, radio, print, OOH, cinema and social media.

Snickers launched the campaign in the US on the perfect stage to create fame: the 2010 Super Bowl. The ad starred Betty White starring as a struggling American Football star who gets tackled until she eats a Snickers and American Football star Bert Belasco returns to his normal self.

Accelerating Growth: global success

The ad was an immediate success, leading to 400 million incremental and unpaid media impressions with a media value equal to $28.6m – 11.4 times the initial investment. In the year after the campaign launched, global sales increased by 15.9% and market share grew in 56 of the 58 markets in which it ran.

Over the last decade the campaign has been awarded 47 Lions, spanning 14 categories and six countries, as well as every major effectiveness award, including two Effectiveness Lions, an IPA gold and global and local Effies and AME Awards. Almost 15 years on and ‘You’re not you when you’re hungry’ remains one of the most recognisable brand slogans.

For well established brands that have already achieved a certain level awareness, it is important to understand what the right objective is to achieve their business goals. In increasingly saturated markets, Snickers’ makes the case for the importance of brand fame in driving sales.

​​​​​​     ​ 

This week for our ESG series we are joined by two wonderful guests in the digital advertising world, John Goulding Global Chief Strategy Officer and Debbi Rosenthal Head of Solutions at MiQ.

John is a media & technology leader with 14 years’ experience in the digital advertising space. As Global Chief Strategy Officer at MiQ he oversees a team of 280 product, engineering and data-science specialists, focused on building technology that improves programmatic campaign outcomes for advertisers and agencies. Prior to MiQ, John worked at A&N Media where he helped to establish a programmatic practice for titles such as Metro, Local World and MailOnline.

Debbi is MiQ’s Head of Solutions, UK, where she leads a team of analytics and technology specialists to deliver innovative programmatic solutions that answer its clients’ most pressing business challenges. Debbi’s previous roles centred on Digital Analytics & Personalisation in both agency and client side. At MiQ, Debbi is passionate about developing the next generation of women innovators in adtech and co-chairs the company’s women’s network, WiQ, as well as being an active member of Bloom and other industry groups.

Q. Tell me about what you’re doing in the ESG and sustainability space at MiQ?

A. John: There are two main areas we can split this into: how we help our clients to become more sustainable and meet their ESG goals and what we are doing to get our own house in order.

Debbi: To speak to the client side, I would say we can break this down into two further categories. Firstly, how we help clients buy with carbon emissions in mind. To do that, we have partnered with Scope 3 (a popular partner and standard bearer for carbon data in the media industry) to access and analyse every impression we serve so it can be tracked and scored. We can then use this data in several ways. One way is private marketplace deals for programmatic buys. This is where clients can buy inventory which MiQ has determined to have lower predicted carbon emissions and is already optimised for a specific client KPI. This results in good performance at the same time as lowering carbon emissions from marketing. Another is to give clients a bespoke “green score”. That green score is calculated from Scope 3’s emissions data for every impression we serve, mapped to create a sustainability index which shows advertisers how their campaign emissions compare to that of their industry and market. This is something we do as standard with all clients running a campaign with us.

The other aspect of how we work with clients on this topic is around creative. We use companies such as Seen This which reduce carbon emissions across different creative formats by loading those creatives in bitesize pieces, therefore reducing wastage.

That’s a snippet of our work from a purely carbon emissions perspective and the only thing that I’d add to that is we don’t use and view sustainability as a marketing KPI on it’s own. A lot of the work we have done to lower carbon emissions and make it easier for clients to buy into has involved creating models off the back of this work which look at campaigns from a multi-KPI view. Therefore, rather than just considering the carbon footprint of a campaign, we tend to consider attention, carbon, and performance metrics in one place to build a holistic approach for clients.

John: When we consider our internal efforts, starting at the ESG level, there’s four areas that are really important for us as a business:

  • Responsible advertising – making sure our ads are well placed, and brand safe, that they include appropriate messaging and that there’s a high level of data privacy among our best practices.
  • DE&I – this is something we’ve been focused on for the past four years. We produce an annual public-facing report that we are really proud of. We feel as though we’re making some really good progress in this space. For example, 47% of our managers are women – up from 33% in 2020, and 27% of our managers are BIPOC, up from 20% in 2020.
  • Employee centricity – ensuring we have an amazing employee experience so we can retain and grow talent while offering training and support.
  • Environment –we have a specific focus on greenhouse gases and reaching Net Zero. We’re only 18 months into the journey in this area. However, we have just produced our first public facing report in 2023 in terms of measuring our carbon footprint. We’re trying to enhance our ability to report accurately every year, implementing a Net Zero strategy to be achieved by 2030 with Scopes 1 and 2 to be met by 2025.

 

Q. Are advertisers and their agencies leaning forward on this topic collaboratively?

A. John: I think if it’s really central to a brand’s identity, then it is the client that’s pushing it and the agency is simply finding creative ways to execute. However, there are some agencies, particularly some of the bigger agencies, where ESG is becoming a central theme. In that instance, there is some momentum and movement on this. The latter camp I believe is more in its initial phases.

 

Q. What percentage of clients are leaning into the data and measurement that’s being produced by agencies?

A. John: Right now it’s the top 5-10% most vocal advertisers for who sustainability is part of the fabric of their brand. Outside of that, we are trying to make this a mainstream option so it’s a win-win for clients. Performance isn’t going to go down just because there’s slightly more focus on ESG. In some cases performance may also improve! It’s just about a mindset and behaviour transition.

 Debbi: I would say there is a lot of interest but also nervousness around the performance side, which is why we have spent a lot of time focusing on the performance aspect of carbon emissions and green scores. The easiest way for us as a managed service to help clients benefit and bring about change in their own media buying is to work on it behind the scenes while still delivering performance. We will still continue to put things like the green scores on Post-Campaign Analysis (PCAs) so that clients are aware. However, this is something our traders can do without needing to obtain serious levels of client buy-in and support as it’s already built into our existing capabilities. We don’t charge anymore for providing this, we wouldn’t increase the CPM for that analysis. It’s a balancing act of the clients asking for it and wanting a lot more, as well as those who just want to dip their toes into this measurement and care more specifically about performance.

 

Q. Are there companies you feel have already demonstrated a robust strategy in this space and if so, what are they doing?

A. Debbi: It depends on what lens you look at ESG through, whether that’s societal or environmental. B Corp registered businesses seem like a good place to start as an indicator of their commitment to ESG, but beyond that there are some bigger brands that really carry this ESG ethos through everything they do. You can see this in brands like The Co-op. The Co-operative Bank’s TV ad last year was a great example of this.

Broadly from the societal and governance side, there are agencies such as Mullen Lowe Agency  that take pride in how they create very best possible employee experience and give back to society. They seem very advanced and strong when it comes to issues such as women’s health and invisible issues.

John: There are companies within the programmatic space really leaning in here too. On the ad tech side, Open X is pushing both to get to Net Zero and elevate the debate. Publishers like The Guardian are also performing well relative to their peers which is a result of their transparency and reporting. It’s encouraging to see this in the data and reassuring us to spend more.

 

Q. What do you think key players in the industry might be focused on in 2024 with regards to an ESG agenda?

A. Debbi: I think we are likely to see, and hopefully see, focus on the broader set of ESG principles outside of just carbon emissions which is a big focal point currently. The industry has had tunnel vision on carbon as the core ESG focus recently, but there’s actually 17 sustainable development goals. When you think of ESG more broadly, all of these contribute towards the CSR initiatives and ESG health of a business. We have worked with companies like Legacy Media, which provides comprehensive ESG scoring (across all principles) for the whole advertising industry; from big top of the chain companies, all the way down to small programmatic businesses. We partnered with them last year to start looking at what micro, end-of-the-chain areas we could have influence over beyond just a carbon emissions standpoint. Agencies and brands are starting to pay more attention to the broader ESG lens. The growth of this data and how it can be used for pitching or planning is beginning to influence how we are running our businesses more effectively in an ESG context. That’s where I see things heading anyway by applying the broader set of principles to business.

John: Slightly intuitively from a MiQ perspective, we are still very focused on carbon, environment and what we can influence. Biodiversity for example we can’t move the needle on but we do need to stay focused on areas that are firmly within our control. One other area I would call out is the responsible advertising space which we view as a sub-sector of ESG. We can actually make a big difference to society through responsible advertising best practices.

 

Q. If you were King and Queen for the day, what ESG policy would you decree?!

A. Debbi: Mine would be to set a minimum bio-diversity standard and automatically enforced. To ensure gardens and green spaces are being utilised correctly by everyone to avoid habitat loss. Although this doesn’t relate at all to anything we do, I think it’s important – unless we plant a wildflower for every impression we serve?!

John: As King of the world (going big), I would go for universal cross-border carbon pricing. Carbon is currently this invisible thing. Often if you’re an emitter of it you don’t have to pay for it – we need to create market forces to solve this problem. In a small way, this is what is starting to happen in programmatic media and we are starting to see the cost of carbon in our supply chain, but it would be amazing to do so long-term on a global scale.

I also think education is extremely important and something we haven’t yet touched on. I wouldn’t blame any brand for not knowing what is causing emissions or what they can do to reduce them through advertising campaigns and media buying. It is important now to bring more people with us on this journey and prove there is some significant stuff we can collectively resolve.

MiQ are a programmatic media partner. It drives business changing results with better connected marketing. It does more with your data to reach new customers, in new ways, wherever they are.

Simon King, Business Director

Next up in our ‘A day in the life’ series, we have Simon King, a Business Director here at MI to share his thoughts about our industry, award winning work and his role models. 

What led you to a career in media?

I did an A level course in media studies, one of the modules was advertising and I just really enjoyed it. I was originally torn between media and journalism, but ultimately, I knew I wanted to go into the media field.

I had planned on going to university to study sports journalism, but before embarking on the student life, I took a break and worked at a local bar. I got chatting to a guy who owned his own advertising agency and he offered me a two week trial. I loved it! There were a few familiar faces working at the agency and I must have impressed because they offered me a job. I worked there for 18 months  learning the ropes and my role offered me a great introduction into the world of media. Once I felt that I had found my feet in the industry with a firm starting block, I decided to venture into London which is when I began my 8 and half year stint at MediaCom. From there I worked at other agencies including Kite Factory and Zenith before joining the team at MI Media.

 

What does a typical day look like?

Well, I don’t need an alarm clock because the kids so kindly wake me up at 5:30. The house is pure chaos: breakfast, getting ready for school, the standard morning drill.

*Kingy pauses… Oh, is this meant to be about my working day?…*

Well in that case, it starts with a morning call with my team which allows me to check-in to see how they are and if their mornings were as chaotic as mine. We address any challenges we may have for that day, check the progress on certain campaigns, what client meetings we have coming up and get a good overview of who is heading up what. Once this is all discussed, my day usually involves speaking to clients and people internally who are working on key projects with my team.

 

What is your proudest moment at MI?

Hands down winning a Performance Marketing Award in Best Integrated Performance Campaign category with my client Pogust Goodhead. The idea for the winning campaign came out of a random conversation with my main client. What started as  a gem of an idea, ended up becoming reality and not only that, but it became a successful, award-winning world cup campaign which took the client from a DRTV advertiser to advertising on huge sporting occasions. The award process is never easy and entering such a competitive category saw us come up against some huge brands, so we were all chuffed to have won.

 

What advice would you give to someone thinking about a career in media?  

Come with an open mind. The industry is massively innovative and constantly evolving, so bear that in mind. Every day is completely different and what excites me most about the world of media is that I am still learning, despite working within this field for a few years now.

As we spend most of our waking hours at work, people need to find something they enjoy. Half the battle is waking up and looking forward to your job. If you nail that, you are in for a good run. Media is a fast paced but exciting industry where you get the opportunity to work on cool brands with interesting partners and media owners. You also get to reap the rewards of the social aspects of our industry, from fun events to being out and about at lunches and dinners.

 

Who would be your dream client to work with?

I am not a massive gamer, but I love the marketing approaches in the gaming industry. From conventional and guerilla media, to the development in tech and AI solutions the gaming sector is forever evolving. Within marketing, you can see the competitive streak shining through as different brands compete with one another. I loved seeing the likes of Travis Scott who collaborated with Fortnite on an in-game experience to promote his track with a concert embedded into the game, that’s pretty out there! That’s what interests me, having a client and sector with an ‘all ears’ approach that is willing to embrace new and exciting concepts and strategies. It’s fresh, it’s cool and it draws people in.

 

Who is your role model and why?

Learning all the good stuff and bad stuff in life is what makes a well-rounded role model for me. Because of that, I have to say my parents. They have shaped me into the person I am today and remind me to always try to be the best version of myself. If I had to pick a celeb, it would be Harry Kane. I not only idolise him as a footballer, but also for being a great person, a great dad and a true family man. He steers clear of the trouble that other football players find themselves in and what some players are sometimes tainted for: going out partying and getting up to nonsense. He is just an all-round successful good egg!

​​​​​​     ​ 

In our next Q&A article of the ESG insights: behind the headline’s series, we are joined by Richard Boon. Richard is CEO of Webmart, a sustainable marketing agency. Webmart is a responsible business and certified B Corp. Richard leads a team of 40 strong team in marketing execution, strategy and technology. Webmart partners with clients in e-commerce, retail and charity, handling £20million of spend across Print, Digital, Creative and Data services.

Q. Tell me about what Webmart is doing currently that relates to ESG and sustainability and how you’re involved…

A. Two things. Firstly, climate action – I’m now spending 25% of my time waking people up to the issue of Scope 3 emissions specifically. That is downstream products and services that have a carbon value to them that are currently invisible or swept under the rug and have very little measurement on them. It’s about educating people that we should be past light sensors in the kitchen and getting people to cycle to work, really that’s like turning up to an earthquake with a dustpan and brush! What we really need to be talking about is that, if the estimated global emissions of digital advertising is 3-5% and growing, we need to be doing something about this to make a change. So, my climate action piece is to take the challenge to others and educating them on carbon literacy.

Secondly, what’s important is providing a solution. We recently won an award for “Highly Commended in the Lloyds Business Excellence Awards” for most sustainable business recognising our work with carbon calculation tools and methodologies, where we can measure digital activity. This includes measurement of website, emails, social posts etc. and creates a carbon value for this activity. It’s the same with physical printed marketing measuring the release of that campaign and its full life cycle. This allows you to get a very different perspective on how to specify a campaign, how long that campaign lasts and what you do with it at the end. We’re enabling agencies, marketers and suppliers to quantify the sustainability impact of a campaign, alongside measuring the usual impacts such as cost and performance.

 

Q. Do you think advertisers should be planning media investment with ESG goals in mind?

A. 100%. I think people should be looking also at carbon budgets placed in different media. We want advertisers to be looking to reach their audience in a way that is both budget friendly and carbon efficient. For example, if you look at the distribution department and the logistics of shipping food, there will be a carbon reduction budget measuring the carbon produced within the shipping process, whereas this wouldn’t necessarily be measured in a marketing plan. So, when looking at different types of media and how we plan it, we should consider not just the value being spent but also the carbon impact. If the client looks across the whole channel mix and plans more effectively with carbon in mind, could they have the same reach but also with a smaller footprint to achieve that reach?

 

Q. Do you think there are other ESG goals outside of carbon that we should be focused on when planning a campaign?

A. As a B Corp, our opinion may evolve over the next few years and indeed it has been evolving for some time. There’s a stance to say you should have red lines when dealing with the fossil fuels industry for example but also there’s an argument to be had around if you are better to work alongside them making the change and helping them to improve. I think the answer for us lies in if they are on the journey and willing to make a change, we would probably consider helping them with the ethical side of things. However, some advertisers may have done too much damage to society already and in this case, we would have to put a red line through ever working with them. There’s quite a fine line between who you will trade with and who you will help. We have some customers who are very responsible and some who are earlier on in their journey.

 

Q. Are advertisers and their agencies leaning forward on this topic collaboratively?

A. I think it varies. Around 25% of our revenue is through our agency partnerships and the other 75% is direct with clients so we see it from both sides. It varies based on the type of business that we’re dealing with and how responsible they are trying to be, both as a business and with their consumers. We don’t tend to always see a hunger for new things. Companies reach a plateau when they’ve met the level their customers are expecting them to be at.

Webmart has been involved in environmental initiatives since 2005. We’ve built this so thoroughly into our business, we might now be slightly ahead of the curve, so we need further client and agency appetite to be able to take our ESG efforts to the next level. Tactics are out there to force positive change, for example the threat of introducing carbon taxes. We have proactively gone over and above within our business to lead the way on the ESG journey and that’s because we only see things moving in one direction.

With agencies and advertisers, I find there isn’t a pull it’s more a push from our side. People are open to conversations, but I’ve seen a lack of agencies reach out to either match what we are doing or collaborate. It feels more like a badge. I get frustrated by the fact that not everyone is on board with the continual improvement cycle. When you are actually trying to do better every year across all areas of ESG, it does feel a little like we are beating our own drum but not everyone else is dancing to the same beat. It is excellent when agencies do come together to work collaboratively, despite being in a potentially competitive environment.

ESG has been put on the back burner on the government’s priority list in recent years due to the economy. However, many businesses have set ambitious net zero targets and I think when the economy starts to repair itself, we will see a big shift in attention on to ESG where businesses have fallen behind on targets and initiatives.

 

Q. Are there companies you feel have already demonstrated a robust strategy in this space and if so, what are they doing?

A. There are several agencies that are doing it quite smartly. There’s some people in the digital space that have some new ways of thinking such as Wholegrain Digital, Climbing Trees, Propellernet. These three in particular stand out to me, not just because of how they are doing ESG within their businesses but because they demonstrate a collaborative alliance and global way of thinking on best practices. I respect that all are under excellent leadership and creating collective cultures that further ESG practices. Wholegrain Digital has a publicised an ethical criteria of who it will work with and who it won’t, which is fairly bold and as a result it will have its niche of client.

In terms of clients, I like what Lucky Saint is doing in the market particularly with its messaging and Toast as well, it reuses bread to make beer and it seems to be smart as a brand.

A client I would mention is Tim Fowler and Alex Barbier, the team at Exodus Travels. They won a gold award with us for with campaign for data hygiene. In 2023 Exodus Travel partnered with Webmart to optimise its existing acquisition direct mail with the aim of amplifying response rates while reducing the campaign’s carbon footprint.  Here’s the full case study.https://www.marketreach.co.uk/case-study/exodus-travels-journey-to-sustainability. We think it’s admirable when a client pushes further for a higher standard, so this is why Exodus deserves the award recognition for embracing sustainable marketing.

 

Q. What do you think key players in the industry might be focused on in 2024 with regards to an ESG agenda?

A. The big one that seems to be hot topic for this year is the conversation around offsetting. There’s been some scrutiny over offsetting, with some seeing it as a box ticking exercise. Some brands are interested in it, others are moving away from it completely as they don’t feel as though it will fulfil their net zero aims. I think it’s probably the year people are going to have access meaningful measurement and there will be a mixture of people waking up being like do we need to do more? Going further than simply offsetting is the stage we are at now. It’s not good enough to just rely on this. Things may get more affordable with carbon capture, sequestration and removal, but until then….offsetting to a gold verified standard is seen as the (controversial) next best. I recommend more focus on measure and reduction before relying on offsetting.

 

Q. If you were King/Queen for the day, what ESG policy would you decree?!

A. The biggest impact we could probably have would be (and I’m going after digital a bit here) that digital needs to get up to speed with carbon calculation. The industry needs to be better disciplined about any data that is created and shared, which is what we refer to as our carbon footprint. My decree would be to implement digital accountability and recycling. If it was all sat in your garage, you wouldn’t have it there so it shouldn’t be different online. All of our “dark data”, storage and wasteful digital ecosystem practices contribute to higher energy and carbon loads. It’s estimated that this digital ecosystem is equivalent to the airline industry of 3-5% of global carbon emissions, it’s just accelerating whilst we all state we are reducing flights. It’s going the wrong way.

Another decree would be that everyone in the industry should take a carbon literacy course so that everyone has the knowledge and education to understand our goals. We need to ensure people are aware of the impact of their behaviours.

 

Webmart was founded by Dr Simon Biltcliffe in 1996. It is entirely self-funded, independent and focused on building trusting and cooperative relationships in the wonderful world of multichannel marketing.  Though its heritage is in buying and managing print services for its customers, these days Webmart is just as likely to consult on driving up marketing ROI through sustainable integrated marketing campaigns as specifying large volume print.

In 2021 it achieved B Corp status, which it is very proud of. It also works tirelessly on lots of environmental initiatives to support the planet including carbon-offsetting and generating energy through solar power. It’s also ISO 14001 environmental certified. Read more about Webmart’s initiatives here.

​​​​​​     ​ 

This February trends article delves into three topics which have hit the headlines and got our attention. We’ve seen a robust growth and optimistic forecasts in ad spend and marketing budgets, read a different angle on the evolving AV landscape as global streaming giants have begun to collaborate to meet industry standards and explored the expanding reach of media owners through strategic partnerships, understanding the potential benefits this has for agencies like us and brands themselves.

 

Trends in spend: Budget growth predictions

It’s been well publicised in the past month that the UK ad market is experiencing strong growth.  Spends are predicted to skyrocket this year with predictions reaching £39bn in 2024, up from £37bn in 2023, based on industry reports from the Advertising Association and WARC. This is mainly influenced by increased online consumer spending and, surprisingly, this isn’t expected to slow down in 2024 despite economic challenges. Based on trends reported at the end of last year, marketing budgets are also growing at their fastest rate in nearly a decade which is a positive and refreshing outlook, particularly for agencies. This optimism about the industry is also supported by the IPA Bellwether Report, which revealed the strongest marketing budgets in almost a decade. The buzz of 2024 major events such as the Euros, the Paris Olympics and the expected UK general election should ensure the upward trend in ad spend is maintained throughout the year.

The AA and WARC have raised their growth forecast for UK ad spend in 2023 to 6.4%, with a further increase of 5.9% expected in 2024. Notably, events marketing performed the best in the final quarter, with a positive balance of 15.9%. Spending on search is expected to rise by 8.7% and online display by 7.4%. TV is set to grow by 1.4%, largely driven by a 14.6% increase in BVOD. Radio and out-of-home advertising are also anticipated to grow by 2.1% and 7.3% respectively, while cinema is expected to grow by 4.6%. However, online classifieds, direct mail, national and regional news brands and magazine brands are forecasted to decline in spending. This is reflective of the trends we are seeing with our clients and hearing from our partners & media owners.

These predictions gives us a lot of hope and excitement for the industry and the year to come.

 

Streaming services pave the way for the changing AV landscape

February saw the headlines that Thinkbox has welcomed Amazon, Disney+, Netflix, Vevo and Warner Bros Discovery as associate members. These companies will support Thinkbox’s marketing activities for TV advertising, contribute to its research program and engage with the media & marketing industry in the UK. The industry then saw Amazon Prime Video joining Barb in a similar move, following Netflix and Disney+. This means viewing data for Prime Video will now be available to Barb subscribers. Amazon’s decision to join Barb coincides with its recent introduction of ads on Prime Video, expanding beyond special programming to all content. Other streaming platforms such as Paramount+ and Now are also Barb subscribers due to their relationships with Channel 5 and Sky.

These moves reflect an evolution in the AV industry as global streaming platforms integrate into traditional measurement systems, these joint memberships underscore the importance of collaboration and standards in the advertising industry. It also demonstrates the rise of streaming and changing viewer habits.

 

Media owners broadening reach through partnerships

It was announced recently that Pinterest has entered into a new ad partnership with Google in a move designed to boost its ad revenue. This marks Google as the second third-party ad partner for Pinterest, following its multi-year collaboration with Amazon that was unveiled last year. This collaboration provides an opportunity for brands running campaigns with Google ads to not only broaden their reach but also engage with an active, high-value consumer base. This has the potential to lead to stronger return on investment and increased conversions. Pinterest initiated the rollout of the new ad integration a few weeks ago and is reportedly experiencing positive results. Following a similar pattern to the Amazon integration, the Google integration is expected to be phased in over several quarters.

From a media agency perspective, this will be an option for us to look into in the future as this is expected to be phased across the next few quarters. It’s likely that, similar to the capabilities of YouTube advertising within the Google ads platform, there will also now be a section for Pinterest advertising which would allow for much better tracking of campaigns, especially for e-commerce clients who are likely to benefit from this roll out. We would also expect to see competition and costs increase within Pinterest as more and more users will now see Pinterest as an easier and simpler way of advertising.

Everyone benefits from this exciting partnership. Pinterest earns valuable advertising revenue to improve user experience and creator tools. Google expands its reach to a more engaged global audience. Creators have the chance to build sustainable income streams and share their passions with the world. Importantly, users will hopefully find exactly what they’re looking for, thanks to more relevant and targeted ads that seamlessly blend into their discovery journey.

 

Sources:

https://www.alfinsight.com/blog/ad-market-outperforming-wider-economy

Advertising Association/WARC media expenditure report

IPA | Q4 2023 IPA Bellwether Report

https://the-media-leader.com/amazon-disney-netflix-vevo-and-warner-bros-discovery-join-thinkbox/

Amazon Prime Video joins Barb

https://yourstory.com/2024/02/google-ads-come-pinterest-new-monetization-path

https://searchengineland.com/pinterest-ad-partnership-google-437390

​​​​​​     ​ 

Our audio-focused February looked into audio’s position in the ever-changing fragmented media landscape, looking at how it has moved beyond conventional broadcast radio with the rise of podcasts and streaming services which are offering more tailored options for brands.

To remain up to date and get the audio inside scoop, we welcomed the likes of Spotify, RadioWorks, Bauer Media and Acast to our offices. From the conversations we heard, the stats and insights speak realms. To put it simply, yes brands should absolutely be looking to implement audio into campaigns to stay ahead of the curve.

RADIO GAGA…

To address how we can maximise audio effectiveness in future campaigns for our clients, Bauer Media displayed radio’s true potential in building trust and audience loyalty. The radio landscape is expanding and lends itself to the shift towards digital devices. As a staggering 43 million people tune in weekly, DAB, digital audio and smart speakers appear to be the go-to devices where consumers access digital radio content. With multiple touchpoints for reaching listeners, it is vital that we are aware of the advertising options available to brands.

Whilst we know that audio is impactful, measuring it is crucial to its success. Radio offers brands a platform that can boost mental availability, driving through-the-funnel metrics. It goes beyond brand awareness to amplify share of voice. Integrating radio into campaigns can not only enhance perception and consideration, but also brand equity, giving brands a significant competitive advantage. Beyond brand, Radio has its role to play in driving revenue, propelling conversions and purchases. Incorporating radio into campaigns has shown a remarkable 42% increase in driving profits.

So how can brands weave their commercial messaging through radio ads? Luckily for us Radioworks was able to provide us with useful insights into how brands can accelerate their growth. Audio’s real attraction include two important green flags: love and trust. Due to this, audio partnerships are able to drive brand uplift whilst intertwining messages into poignant moments. Back in Q4 2022, Mind ran a partnership with talkSPORT encouraging listeners to break away from the mental health taboo. Whilst this campaign most likely shocked listeners, Mind positioned itself in a way to access a new audience at just the right time, during a major tournament and in the lead up to the festive period.

Whilst sticking to what we know can be tempting, stepping out of comfort zones and away from traditional advertising can really pay off with figures showing that partnerships can be up to two times more effective than traditional advertising, with 43% uplift when partnerships are live.

LISTENING, TALKING & ESCAPE ROUTES

If you were to ask your friends or family if they had or are listening to a podcast, a large amount of people would admit to having a podcast on the go, whether it be My Therapist Ghosted Me , The Diary Of A CEO or The Newlyweds. Podcasts are now fully embedded in our daily routines, with 60% of the UK listening and 45% of the UK streaming more audio since the pandemic. The last few years have ignited the flame in current and new podcast listeners.

Spotify has gone that extra mile to ensure that it has mastered the art of understanding their listeners’ mood, moment and mindset; meaning that adverts can be delivered based on users’ habits. Brands have to potential to reach 1 in 3 adults in the UK each week with Spotify’s 26.8m monthly users listening. Podcasts are sparking conversation and playing a vital role in getting the world talking. Whilst people still and will continue to watch the big screen, many are now listening to podcasts that correlate to their favourite TV show. Cast your minds back to the devastating exit of Dianne…following this episode, more people tuned into the podcast: Traitors Uncloaked than Love Island.

Acast shed light on how this hyper relevancy in podcasts can be boosted through geo and time targeting, giving brands a huge opportunity to drive awareness and reach, with podcast sponsorship being the bread and butter for driving consideration and building trust.

Podcasts are going beyond entertainment purposes becoming  a simple way for people to steer away from the noise that comes with the digital world and other unhealthy habits. 75% of people want to cut down on their screen time, with 60% finding that podcasts provide them with a break from other media. Despite the fact that social media provides us with platforms to allow for increased connectivity, figures show that Gen Z is concerned about time spent on social media and the negative repercussions this may have, from poor well-being to too much visual stimulation. Because of this, Gen Z is the front row audience for podcasts, with the audio platform acting as their space to escape.

ANSWERS & APPROACHES

It Is clear that podcast listening is soaring, so how can brands make the most of this? Acast assured us that there is a podcast advertising format fit for every purpose, whether that be direct audio adverts to drive awareness and reach, host read sponsorships or minutes of creative branded segments.

It is a joy to hear that brands’ questions can be answered with a variety of ad options. Advertising options on Spotify can not only be determined between screenless and lean in moments, but streaming intelligence can dictate whether audio or video ads should be served, meaning those active on their phone screen will be displayed with video content, whilst those who are purely listening will hear an audio based ad. Brands’ messaging can be hyper targeted, whether a beauty brand wants to sponsor a ‘good vibes’ playlist or a Charity brand opts for a Video Sponsored Session approach where listeners are gifted 30 minutes of uninterrupted listening in exchange for an attentive video view of the charity’s core message.

Ultimately, we know that radio works, but it’s about thinking innovatively about the best possible approaches for our clients and prospects. It goes without saying, audio is on the up and with it being a constant go to for the majority of us in our day-to-day routines, there are ample opportunities for brands to get their ads to the ears of the right listeners.

 

​​​​​​     ​ 

TV is accelerating rapidly and it is vital that as an agency we remain ahead of the curve by digesting the valuable insights that are on offer across the industry. Campaigns TV Advertising Summit provided us with ample information; from how we can utilise measurement and data solutions, to how we can ensure that we make money go that extra mile by placing brands in front of the right audiences.  

Why TV still matters 

Whilst we find ourselves in an era where streaming services and digital content are hugely prevalent, TV continues to hold its own. Ben Frow, Content Chief, Paramount reminded us that linear is still loved. Despite the rise of on-demand platforms, linear TV remains significant with traditional television networks such as Channel 5 still experiencing weighty viewership numbers. It’s enlightening to know that TV is still able to break through the noise and withstand the ever-evolving media landscape, but we need to remain adaptable to changing viewer habits.

So how can we remain successful within this field? We must ensure we are knowledgeable in the two main areas. Knowing a brands audience and its competitors. When people say the customer is always right, the same approach goes to audience views and motivation. We may not always agree with their views, but we have to ensure that we always bear the audience in mind. There are small adaptations that can really capture audiences, for example being explicitly specific by putting a geography such as “Yorkshire” in a programme title will no doubt result in viewers from Yorkshire tuning in. 

Frow underscored the power of live TV in developing collective experiences, an element that can be said to be lacking in streaming services. This collective engagement remains a unique strength of linear TV, enhancing the impact of advertising and fostering brand association with compelling content.

 

Engagement through emotion  

In the constantly changing landscape of media consumption Tom Sherwood, Product Lead, Google reminded us why we are drawn to our TV screens. He outlined the four key continuing needs: stimulate & entertain, do & learn, connect to others and self-identity & growth. Keeping these needs in mind can help content creators and advertisers craft more engaging experiences.  

Panellists reminded us how TV is often viewed as being a channel with a real pulse. It provides an opportunity for brands to place themselves in moments of emotional engagement, not all mediums can reach viewers in the comfort of their own living rooms. TV allows consumers to resonate with content as visual information is easier to digest, the reaction and conversations that followed ITV’s Mr Bates vs The Post Office is a prime example of how programmes have the ability to capture attention and make viewers lean in.  

Brands that associate themselves with regular, consistent TV content can see the effects of positive reinforcement, tapping into viewers routine habits as they tune in to channels at specific times. TV not only enables brands to intertwine their messaging into specific programmes, but also enables them to meet viewers on the platforms that they want to consume, whether that be considered browsing(consciously) or instinctively watching content that appears on feeds (unconsciously).   

Cross media measurement in a convergent world  

Measuring success in this convergent media landscape comes with various challenges. Thankfully there are many upcoming solutions.  Origin, which assists advertisers in understanding campaign coverage by capturing the value of advertising in the regularly changing consumer environment, aims to integrate cross-media measurement to facilitate better-informed decisions for advertisers and agencies. The likes of Amazon, Meta and Google are homing in on quality of impression with factors such as sound on, length of viewability and outcome-based measurement. 

As the industry navigates these complexities, the importance of context and content remains central. Origin seeks to provide a standardised framework for evaluating ad effectiveness, though challenges like the lack of BVOD data at the outset and disparities in data richness across platforms persist. 

As we look ahead to the remainder of 2024, we will remain vigilant in our approach, bearing in mind the challenges that we may face, and adaptations can be put in place.  

 

Unlocking and understanding CTV’s evolving landscape 

CTV’s importance is evident through platforms like BVOD and YouTube, though a current lack in advertiser confidence for planning and buying it will be something to overcome through collaboration and transparency. As SVOD integrates advertising, there’s a resurgence in the potential for 30-second ads, but with linear TV’s decline in January, adaptation is crucial for creatives and brands to navigate between broadcast and addressable mediums, ensuring effective spending by understanding audience behaviour. 

The clash between TV audiences and internet users continues and a nuanced approach is essential. While emerging platforms offer niche targeting opportunities, traditional TV maintains its relevance, particularly in reaching broad audiences effectively. Adapting to this evolving landscape requires us to be careful not to be immediately wowed by the technical data that some of the providers are able to give. Instead, we need to make sure that we continue to push hard about the depth of data that is available.  

 

It is clear that the TV landscape still has plenty to offer for brands, remaining a channel full of emotive influence where brands can intertwine their messaging with compelling content. As we look ahead to the rest of 2024, we must carefully balance between embracing innovation and preserving the strengths of traditional television. 

​​​​​​     ​ 

In our next ESG interview, we speak to Aisha Graham, Production Manager at Happy Hour Productions to hear a view from the creative side of the industry. Aisha joined Happy Hour in 2018. Prior to advertising, Aisha worked in manufacturing but decided on a career change and moved to Bristol to start her career in media. At Happy Hour, Aisha spearheads sustainability initiatives, processes and practices within the business. 

Q. Tell me about what Happy Hour are doing currently that relates to ESG and sustainability and your involvement in this.

A. Throughout my life I have felt strongly about environmental, social issues and injustices. I come from a family of social workers and dare I say, hippies, who care immensely about sustainability (both out of need and responsibility) and about fairness for all. This foundation seeped into all aspects of my life and career which developed into an attachment to ESG within the workplace.

At Happy Hour, I spearhead our sustainability initiatives, processes and practices (e.g. paperless office, switching to reusable cups and flasks, refillable hand soap bottles, swapping paper for cotton towels, working with our cleaners to use 100% eco-friendly products, hiring electric vans for shoots and more). I also organised a work placement for five Bristol students to gain experience in the notoriously hard to break-into TV industry. I am always striving for improvements and updates to business practices and accountability, community engagement and diversity & inclusion. And I am committed to staying informed and taking steps towards addressing ESG issues, through both work and personal actions.

Outside of work, I am always trying to reduce my family’s carbon footprint. I shop in our local refill grocery store, use cloth nappies for our baby, don’t eat meat and last year we upgraded to an electric car which has been incredible.

As an SME, Happy Hour has the unique opportunity to engage all co-workers in the development and continual refinement of our ESG strategy and principles.

Our workplace culture is ‘earth-first’, and we’re proud that over 85% of our employees either cycle, walk, use public transport or drive an electric vehicle to work. We have also introduced other initiatives to reduce our environmental footprint, such as:

  • Using 100% renewable energy suppliers
  • Promoting a paperless office (we’re almost there!)
  • Creating and implementing a sustainability-focused shoot guidelines policy which leads with the five ‘Rs’ – Refuse, Reduce, Reuse, Repurpose and Recycle. This is especially important as, when it comes to shooting, elements like props, sets, lighting, catering transport etc. can contribute hugely to landfill waste and carbon emissions
  • Building relationships and switching contracts to local businesses that have certifiable green credentials
  • Actively involving and training staff with organisations such as AdGreen, Albert, Green Alliance, Giki Zero. Here’s a little more info on these businesses:

AdGreen: Its purpose is to motivate the advertising industry to reduce the negative environmental impacts of production and enable the community to measure and understand waste and carbon emissions.

Albert: Is the home of environmental sustainability for the screen industries – to share, learn and act on our impact, including free, bespoke training days to everyone in the TV and film industries.

Green Alliance: Is an independent think tank and charity focused on ambitious leadership for the environment. Since 1979, it has been working with the most influential leaders in business, NGOs and politics to accelerate political action and create transformative policy for a green and prosperous UK.

Giki Zero: Is a B Corp and United Nations Race To Zero Accelerator for employee engagement, led by sustainability professionals and supported by climate experts, on a mission to help people cut carbon.

 

Q. Do you think advertisers/ clients should be planning media investment with ESG goals in mind?

A. Absolutely. Consumers value brands that demonstrate a commitment to environmental and social responsibility. Advertisers and clients should consider ESG factors in their media planning to not only contribute to sustainability but also to appeal to a conscientious consumer base. By doing this, they can not only make a positive environmental impact but also enhance their brand reputation.

 

Q. Are advertisers/clients and their agencies leaning forward on this topic collaboratively?

A. Yes, we’ve seen a noticeable shift towards collaborative efforts between advertisers and agencies in addressing ESG issues. Many clients now see the value in aligning their brands with sustainability goals and agencies are proactively incorporating ESG considerations into their strategies. This collaboration is fostering a more responsible and ethical approach to advertising, creating a win-win situation for brands, agencies, production companies and consumers alike. This almost always plays a part in the pitch/tender process and can start as early as the RFI, with clients wanting to make sure that their supply chain is supporting them in achieving their ESG goals.

 

Q. Who is inspiring you or innovating in this area at the moment?

A. From a creative point of view, we’ve recently seen a couple of genius, hard hitting ads which went out in the run up to COP28.

The first by Lucky Generals really makes us think about our individual carbon footprints when it comes to pensions and how/where they’re invested. The ad uses actress Olivia Coleman to deliver a satirical message about the damage that obliviously investing into pension funds is having on the environment, cleverly using humour and emotion to deliver hard hitting messages.

Check out the ad here

The second is by 4Creative, developed to promote Channel 4’s Climate Change Season and question the damage being done by those at the top. It pokes fun at those stereotypes in power who aren’t taking climate change seriously, asking are they doing enough to reduce their “carbon skid mark”. It certainly raises a few eyebrows and gets you thinking!

Check out the ad here

 

Q. If you were King/Queen for the day, what ESG policy would you decree?!

A. That all able-bodied, employed adults do compulsory water-ways clean-ups, once a week, for three hours. Whether rivers, ponds, seas or oceans, wherever is local to them. This time would be within working hours and would be classed as a minimum ‘donation’ from each employer to the climate emergency.

Happy Hour Productions is a leading TV and video advertising agency, covering everything from animation to live action, all delivered in-house, under one big, happy roof in Bristol. It is currently ranked in the top 35 creative agencies in the UK, and in the top two outside London.

Happy Hour is well experienced in developing original TV ads and video content for clients of all shapes and sizes, from scale-ups to well-known brands, across all sectors including retail, food & drink, education, financial services, property and travel.

 

​​​​​​     ​ 

We have kicked off the week with some positive news.

It is fair to say that the previous few months have been a whirlwind for our team, from new business pitches to getting new and exciting work over the line. Throughout this, our team as always have remained dedicated, enthusiastic and driven to deliver nothing but the best for our clients and prospects.  

We understand that a pitch requires a whole team effort. We want to ensure that everyone is involved within the process, whether that be in the room or those who assist in the research and planning phase. Whilst we strive to deliver for our clients, we recognise the extensive effort and pressures that can come with the pitch process.

As we are committed to establishing a positive experience, we have opted to officially sign up to a great initiative led by the IPA – the Pitch Positive Pledge.

So, what does this mean for us as an agency?

From a new business standpoint, it signifies our commitment to a standardised and accountable pitching process. This includes maintaining quality briefs, reasonable requests and appropriate timelines.

From an agency perspective, it goes without saying that our people are our number one, so we really focus on prioritising our team’s well-being. We work as a united team and with that comes with strongly formed relationships. Ultimately, we are here to back each other up every step of the way.  

To streamline our pitching process, we are aware of our responsibilities as an agency and see the importance of cutting through the noise, by ensuring our clients make it clear on what they don’t want to see at a pitch and not wasting advertisers time through diligent work.  

We strive to continue on our positive path by harnessing this momentum to accelerate growth for our clients whilst fostering agency growth in the right way.  

​​​​​​     ​ 

We’re delighted to introduce this week’s guest Laura Chase, Chief Commercial Officer at WeAre8, a digital ecosystem built to transform the $800 bn digital ad market by putting people, Publishers and our planet at the heart of the economics.

Laura leads the WeAre8 commercial team, playing an integral role in launching and growing the platform in the UK. As part of this, she has developed partnerships with all major agency networks and created WeAre8’s Publisher partnership framework, onboarding PinkNews, Hello! and The Independent.

Prior to WeAre8, Laura spearheaded Hearst’s social responsibility and sustainability offerings and lead the creative solutions and experiential team. Laura has experience leading high performing sales, partnerships & content teams and is deeply committed to transforming the ad industry by putting people and the planet first.

Q. Tell me about what WeAre8 is doing currently that relates to ESG and sustainability.

A. Our whole business is built with ESG in mind. Sue Fennessy, our inspirational Founder and CEO, wanted to address the negative societal and environmental impacts social media and digital advertising has created across the world, all whilst offering brands a more effective, transparent and waste free ad model.

At the heart of our ecosystem is our hate free social app.  WeAre8’s first-in-market verification process enables us to eliminate hateful and harmful content giving our citizens a premium, elevated and inspiring feed that leaves them feeling positive.  When people choose to watch ads on WeAre8, 60% of every £1 or $1 that comes into our business is given back to people, charities and the planet.

Our ad model is a far more sustainable choice for brands.  Because people consciously and intentionally choose to watch each and every ad, we are able to completely eliminate e-waste.  WeAre8 also invests in climate solutions, in partnership with Ecologi, helping projects in the world’s hardest hit areas every time an ad is viewed.

 

Q. In terms of your advertising portfolio, it must be a no brainer for Charities but are you finding that the big corporates are also very interested, or others in-between?

A. Yes – it’s a real mix. We’ve worked with some of the world’s biggest brands over the past couple of years including Unilever, McDonalds, Nike, Nestle, Mars, eBay, Mondelez, Heineken, Audi. It is great that so many brands are focused on improving their ESG impact and spending their budget somewhere more meaningful. The important thing that we always remind brands and agencies is that with WeAre8, you don’t need to compromise on performance to make positive impact. With every campaign on the app brands will get 67X more attention than on Instagram and can expect to see CTR’s of around 5%.

We should be a BAU partner and all of the positive impact that happens behind the scenes supports brands in delivering against the corporate ESG goals.

 

Q. Are advertisers and agencies leaning forward on this area collaboratively, do you think one is pushing more than the other?

A. Some (brilliant) clients really lean in and others are driven by their agency. There’s a lot of positive intent across the industry, but we all do need to come together more to force the change we want and need to see.

Everyone – clients, agencies and media owners can and absolutely should be doing more and pushing each other.  Progress over perfection.

We should also be sharing and celebrating new innovations, best practice and brilliant people more.

 

Q. Are there any brands you see implementing a robust strategy in this space and if so, what are they doing?

A. One client that we work with who really stands out for me is giffgaff. There is an amazing team over there who are deeply committed to collaborating, learning and improving. More generally, brands such as Vinted, eBay, Backmarket are inspiring others through their concepts and are important in driving change and the circular economy.

 

Q. Outside of the brands themselves, are there any other people/partners/companies who are inspiring you?

A. Scope 3 is excellent. It works tirelessly to help agencies and brands make better media choices – offering new tools and services to improve the industry.

I also want to shout out to someone in my team at WeAre8, Jess Stead. Jess is still fairly early on in her career, but she is deeply committed to her own knowledge and how she can do her bit to contribute towards positive ESG change within her work. She does a lot of it off her own back. We need people like this coming through.

 

Q. What do you think will be the focus of the industry in 2024 with regards to an ESG agenda?

A. Reducing and eliminating fraud and e-waste is critical. The internet is now worse for the environment than air travel. Brands and agencies should all be focusing attention on how they do more with less. From a wider ESG perspective also mental health, kindness and supporting each other is key for brands to consider. Not just how we show up, but where we show up. We need to think about how we can make media as an industry healthier for humanity.

There’s lots of positive things happening already which gives me hope.  We just need much more of it.

 

Q. If you were Queen for the day what ESG policy would you decree?

A. More than one (sorry)…

  1. Enforce the criminalisation of hateful and harmful content
  2. More reward and recognition for the businesses and people doing the best work in the sustainability space. We should make them all feel like absolute heroes so future generations are inspired to take a cleaner, greener more planet friendly path.

 

About WeAre8

WeAre8 is all about making a BIG impact on the world through small daily actions. People can get paid and change the world every time they watch an ad with WeAre8 – either in app or with our premium publisher partners on the open web.